Re: Can someone say that some music is Wrong?

by Thomandy Tue Feb 24, 2009 1:37 am

Admin Andrew wrote:Yea, Mozart was probably the most naturally gifted composer of all time. I can't think of anyone that can match him. Bach is a possibility but Bach had a lot of skill where Mozart was just so talented. It's very hard to compare the two since they accomplished things in different ways.

Yeah, I read that Chopin didnt have the same natural composing-gift as composers like them. And that he used a lot more
time on the compositions. But I like Chopins music a lot more than Mozart and Bach... They can have some cool ones, but Im more in the Romantic era. Beethoven is a close second in my book atm. Liszt is up there as well.

https://www.youtube.com/user/FranzFerencLiszt

This might be that Channel on YT with the most recordings of music from Bach to you name it. Smile

Lots of different playlists from Chopin and Liszst ect. First time I got to hear more Liszt than La Campanella and Libestraum Razz

Because of this channel. Check it out!

by Thomandy Tue Feb 24, 2009 1:42 am

maggiekedves wrote:
Thomandy wrote:
maggiekedves wrote:You were not born as Mozart but composing or improvising...

How do you know that? hehe

If you are, you woke up a little late He was already discovered as a musical prodigy at age 3-4, he started to compose music from age 5, he wrote his first opera at age 11, but he only live till age 35 leaving the audience with over 600 pieces.

Game on, good luck

Okay, so then I have about 7-8 year til I should have composed an Opera then? Wink

haha
If I got to choose Id rather be born a Chopin-Type than a Mozart-type Smile

I was actually called a Prodigy the other day by a Performing Pianist/Singer from Usa Smile

hehehe

by Marnex Wed Feb 25, 2009 5:27 am

Thomandy wrote:
pianohama wrote:
Thomandy wrote:
Pianokid220 wrote:...
there is no right or wrong in music

My thoughts exactly

I'm not disagreeing with you, I actually share you opinion in this matter, but he might not see it the same way that you and I do.. he has also about 14 years more experience than me, so I'm just gonna let this one slide, lol!

No, its obvious that he dont see it the same way. But he also say that Beethoven was WRONG when he used that accompany to Fur Elise!! He say in a mail to me that Easy Accompany like Beethovens Fur Elise is WRONG haha
Cause basically I use the same accompany in my piece!

He makes it clear that he dont like Fur Elise and Beethovens accompany in this video, but Can he say that Beethovens way of accompny was WRONG??? That is basically what Im asking.

I just saw this comment from him:
"And to you Wooo... i know wath is right and what wrong in the music!!! "

Wow is he serious about Beethoven?? Anyways in response to music being wrong.......I don't agree with him. He can give his opinion as in if he liked it or not but saying it was wrong!?! Anyways I think Beethoven was pretty talented too. The fact that he was def and still wrote some beautiful compositions was amazing. In fact he cut the legs of his piano and he put it on the ground to feel the vibrations of the music.......I wouldn't have thought of that lol.

by Sponsored content

Sun	Mon	Tue	Wed	Thu	Fri	Sat
	1	2	3	4	5	6
7	8	9	10	11	12	13
14	15	16	17	18	19	20
21	22	23	24	25	26	27
28	29	30