Question about enharmonic notes / scales
2 posters
Andrew Furmanczyk Piano Academy :: Learn How To Play Piano :: Piano Related Discussions :: Piano Scales
Page 1 of 1
Question about enharmonic notes / scales
Just something I thought about...
Lets say: B major....It has 5 sharps...So the relative minor G# minor also has 5 sharps....
G# minor can also be called Ab minor...But Ab minor has 7 sharps...
But they share the exact same notes...What is point of adding two extra sharps when calling it Ab minor?
And C# minor for example, can you call that key Db minor? Cus the latter is not in the circle of fifths?
Or F# minor? Can you name that scale Gb minor?
I would really appreciate if someone could clear this up for me....
Thanks a lot..
Lets say: B major....It has 5 sharps...So the relative minor G# minor also has 5 sharps....
G# minor can also be called Ab minor...But Ab minor has 7 sharps...
But they share the exact same notes...What is point of adding two extra sharps when calling it Ab minor?
And C# minor for example, can you call that key Db minor? Cus the latter is not in the circle of fifths?
Or F# minor? Can you name that scale Gb minor?
I would really appreciate if someone could clear this up for me....
Thanks a lot..
axxe- Beginner pianist
- Number of posts : 10
Guru Points : 0
Registration date : 2010-03-25
Re: Question about enharmonic notes / scales
Hi Axxe,
It is not actually correct to say that Ab minor has 7 sharps. It is correct to say that it has seven flats (Ab,Bb,Cb,Db,Eb,Fb,Gb). C# minor is not referred to as Db minor, probably because one would then either have to write the scale notes as (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,A,B) which repeats the letter A and misses C, (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,A,Cb) which repeats the letter A and misses B, or (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,Bbb,Cb) which uses all the letters but requires a double flat in the key signature. By calling it C# minor we can write out the notes as (C#,D#,E,F#,G#,A,B), which uses all the letters and involves only #s. F# minor is not referred to as Gb minor for the same reasons. Note, however, that we can call C# Major Db Major, and F# Major Gb Major as these problems don't arise with these Major scales.
Below is a list of all the Major keys and their relative minors (with enharmonic names), and their key signatures.
Major...........Key Sig..........minor
C....................-...................A
G....................1#................E
D....................2#................B
A....................3#................F#
E.....................4#...............C#
B/Cb................5#/7b...........G#/Ab
F#/Gb..............6#/6b...........D#/Eb
C#/Db..............7#/5b...........A#/Bb
Ab...................4b.................F
Eb...................3b.................C
Bb...................2b.................G
F.....................1b.................D
Hope this clears things up.
It is not actually correct to say that Ab minor has 7 sharps. It is correct to say that it has seven flats (Ab,Bb,Cb,Db,Eb,Fb,Gb). C# minor is not referred to as Db minor, probably because one would then either have to write the scale notes as (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,A,B) which repeats the letter A and misses C, (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,A,Cb) which repeats the letter A and misses B, or (Db,Eb,Fb,Gb,Ab,Bbb,Cb) which uses all the letters but requires a double flat in the key signature. By calling it C# minor we can write out the notes as (C#,D#,E,F#,G#,A,B), which uses all the letters and involves only #s. F# minor is not referred to as Gb minor for the same reasons. Note, however, that we can call C# Major Db Major, and F# Major Gb Major as these problems don't arise with these Major scales.
Below is a list of all the Major keys and their relative minors (with enharmonic names), and their key signatures.
Major...........Key Sig..........minor
C....................-...................A
G....................1#................E
D....................2#................B
A....................3#................F#
E.....................4#...............C#
B/Cb................5#/7b...........G#/Ab
F#/Gb..............6#/6b...........D#/Eb
C#/Db..............7#/5b...........A#/Bb
Ab...................4b.................F
Eb...................3b.................C
Bb...................2b.................G
F.....................1b.................D
Hope this clears things up.
georger- Beginner pianist
- Number of posts : 9
Location : Australia
Guru Points : 3
Registration date : 2008-12-22
Similar topics
» question on contrary motion scales
» My Question about notes!!
» Minor scales (three different scales?)
» Beginner question! How to play these notes?
» Minor scales basics - question
» My Question about notes!!
» Minor scales (three different scales?)
» Beginner question! How to play these notes?
» Minor scales basics - question
Andrew Furmanczyk Piano Academy :: Learn How To Play Piano :: Piano Related Discussions :: Piano Scales
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Sat Oct 26, 2013 3:15 am by RNewcome
» What's Happened...?
Sun Mar 24, 2013 10:57 pm by Rayman
» Thomas's Performances - NEW Liszt Moments Musicaux D.01 - Page 39
Thu Jun 21, 2012 4:16 pm by Thomandy
» latin rhythms on piano
Wed Jun 06, 2012 7:49 am by jazzylady
» What is the deal with time signatures with a bottom number of 16?
Wed May 23, 2012 8:13 am by Matthieu Stepec
» Piano Dog's Lick of The Week
Sun May 20, 2012 2:17 pm by kentaku_sama
» How to span notes
Wed May 09, 2012 9:55 pm by Matthieu Stepec
» Great sight reading exercises
Tue May 08, 2012 6:11 am by Matthieu Stepec
» Hey guys! How's it going?
Sun Jan 29, 2012 10:43 am by surehit123